I’m struggling again with the lack of support I desire/maybe need related to my open adoption situation. As a result I am motivated to write about my struggles. My daughter, Sri, is a teenager and about to turn 18 years old in a couple months. Lately she has again shared personal dilemmas she is facing at home and is unsure what to do about them. I have so many differing emotions regarding her home life, and I feel torn between supporting Sri (what I see as the best for her) and supporting her relationship with her mother. For some reason I can’t seem to reconcile the two. Believe me I want to!! I wish it were that easy.
But what Dee sees as priorities for Sri, and what I see as priorities for Sri are not the same! Do Dee and I actually sit down and discuss Sri’s current situation and future face-to-face and how to support one another in our roles in Sri’s life? No, not currently. (We used to, to some extent. But in the last couple years we rarely discuss anything about Sri and when we do, it is only briefly on the phone.) Dee and I seem to have allowed walls of misunderstanding and judgement to separate us. I believe this is due to my attempts to be more honest with Sri and Dee in the last couple years (which seems to have caused Dee to feel rejected by me) and due to rebukes I received from Dee for choices I’ve made, independently of Dee, in my relationship with Sri. Consequently we’ve grown apart.
I avoid conversations with Dee when I question her choices for Sri as I learned my lesson long ago…that my views and opinions on parenting matters are not welcome. That is understandable because I AM NOT THE PARENT! Unfortunately Dee has welcomed my views when they support her own and has, at times, enlisted me in chastising Sri. The issue was clothing choices-such as Sri wearing low cut blouses. Unfortunately Sri did not enjoy being confronted by the two of us and only stood her ground even more. Go figure!! Somehow in these situations I end up being the “bad guy” and Dee comes out “the protector”…hmmm….. It didn’t take me long to learn my lesson.
But watching the a-parents make significantly different choices in parenting issues brings up a host of feelings-and then, as the birthparent in the open adoption, you just have to become very good at masking your feelings. Being someone from a social work/therapeutic background myself, I have to ask “How is that healthy?” Where does one turn when these situations are difficult to deal with? Well…over the years I have turned to counselors (try to talk to someone who has not been in the open adoption experience and hope to hear helpful, unbiased feedback-not!) and to journaling, but I’m often still left feeling very alone in this open adoption experience.
Soooo what to do when Dee is making decisions with Sri’s life that I am seriously concerned about and/or with which I totally disagree? Shockingly I have begun to consider seeking counseling with the agency through whom I placed-just to see what they would say! Of course, it would probably not take a genius to figure out their feedback, considering Dee was once an employee of the same agency. But then maybe I am being too judgemental! It is hard to know whether I would get unbiased feedback from an adoption agency!!! Yes!! There is this crazy part of me that wants to believe they care about me and about the outcome of our open adoption experience. But then I think well…but where have they been for the last 17 years?? I know that the a-mom has gone to them on various occasions for support of one kind or another. At one time she even mentioned that I may be asked to come in for family counseling with her and Sri, but that never materialized.
Actually I say I want feedback or input, but I have to admit, also, that I am reluctant/scared to seek it out! And to top it off I’m currently in a boundaries group! Wow! Talk about guilt and confusion!
What I want and desire really is to sit down with other birthmoms, maybe even a group of people from each area of the triad (and I mean a group!) to discuss and receive feedback. Maybe it is time to go on a search again for just such a gem!
In the meantime these are some of the thoughts that go through my head…
- One part of me want to rescue Sri by confronting Dee with my concerns.
- A part of me just wants to bury my head in the sand, hoping Sri will just get through somehow on her own.
- And another part of me wants to believe I can somehow guide Sri in working out the solution/compromise with her mother that will allow both of them to grow towards independence and at the same time maintain a loving relationship.
My mind is drawn back in time to an adoption memoir I read a couple years ago by Patricia Dischler. Her memoir is “Because I Loved You”. I have struggled with the title to her book for several years now, but that is an issue for another post someday. What I’m thinking about now is how she handled her son during his teen years…here is an excerpt from Patricia Dischler’s book “Because I Loved You”
“As Joe grew into his teenage years, not only did his body go through drastic changes, but his relationship with his parents, and with me, had growing pains…
As all teenagers do, he tested his parents, and he had fantasies about a different life with me. When he was fourteen, he came to stay with my parents for a week. That weekend Steve and I and Karen her husband camped in their campground and spent time with Joe. We had brought our waverunners and had a blast all weekend out on the river. Sunday afternoon Karen and Joe had gone up to Mom’s house to get some supplies, and Joe said to her, “I can’t believe I missed out on all this.”
Karen asked what he meant. He said that we seemed to have such great lives and he wished he could have been a part of it. Karen understood that he was thinking that if I had kept him, the fun he had just experienced that weekend would be his everyday life. She quickly set him straight.
Karen told Joe firmly that everything he saw around him that day would not exist if had kept him. She explained how each member of the family was affected by that decision and how it set our lives in courses that were different from what they would have been otherwise. She pointed out that she knew that if I had kept Joe I would have stayed in Dubusque. This meant Karen would have never taken the chance to move to Madison. She never would have met her husband or switched careers and been as successful as she was. The waverunners, our cars, our lifestyles, our husbands all would have been different. She told him he was foolish to believe that this is what his life would have been. She told him to be thankful for all he did have because if I had kept him, he most likely would not have had half of the opportunities his parents had given him. My family had too much respect for his parents to let him be disrespectful in anyway.
When she told me about the conversation, I decided to back away for awhile. Since meeting, Joe and I had begun writing to each other. He was visiting my parents a couple times a year, and I would always join him there. But for the remainder of his teen years I only sent short cards, and I only stayed for a day if he was at my parents. A few times I didn’t go at all. It was very painful to do this, but I’m glad I did. My family had a very difficult time understanding. It was so easy for them to be his family-it didn’t infringe on anyone else’s feelings. But I knew that by getting close to him during these years I was risking having him fantasizing even more about having me for a mother instead of Kathy. That was something I couldn’t tolerate. I wasn’t about to let him believe for a second that if she made him mad (which every mother of a teenager will do eventually!) that he could decide to run away from her and come to me. Again, I knew I had to let go in order for him to grow.” (Because I Loved You, pp. 213-214 copyright 2006)
Dealing with possible “games played by child or parents”, the times when your parenting styles, values, ideas differ significantly from the a-parents, the imploring questions and difficulties you face in relationship with the child you placed are all challenging aspects of an open adoption. And to top it off the support you need to make the best decisions for all involved is either non-existent or minimal and usually extremely biased.
I, too, have considered backing off/walking away for a time because I find this part of the open adoption experience so hard to deal with. But unlike Patricia I have not chosen to walk away. Of course our situations and views of the adoption experience seem to be quite different, and I, also, have to take into consideration the recent loss Sri experienced with the death of her a-father. Anyway I’m sticking it out…still wondering WHAT IS IN THE BEST INTEREST of Sri!? I did back off on requesting visits earlier this year…but getting together again with Sri recently…I couldn’t see a positive impact from the distance for her. And, in fact, it seemed Sri was now facing even more issues and possibly felt like she had no where to turn for mature input. Actually she just seemed more confused than ever about her path in life and has been making decisions in an effort to please everyone around her to her own detriment! Arrgghh!! What to do??!! What to do??!!
Most of us in the adoption triad understand that adoption is not the panacea that much of society believes it to be. There is sooo much work yet to be done to bring about a greater understanding about the impact of adoption on each member of the triad and to truly prepare those seeking ‘adoption as an option’ for their journey ahead. There are various groups that support and aid reunions between birthparents and adoptees and work for more rights for adoptees regarding open records. And, yes, there has been a move towards more openness in adoptions over the last two decades. But what has been the motivating factors? Depending on who you talk to, you will get different answers. I, for one, BEING INVOLVED IN A TRULY OPEN ADOPTION FOR THE LAST 17+ YEARS, want each and every young woman who is considering an open adoption to know that EVEN THE OPEN ADOPTION EXPERIENCE WILL BE MORE PAINFUL AND CONFUSING THAN YOU WILL BE TOLD OR CAN IMAGINE!
MORE THAN ANYTHING WHAT EVERYONE IN THE ADOPTION TRIAD NEEDS IS MORE SUPPORT, EDUCATION, SUPPORT, GUIDANCE, SUPPORT, RESPECT, APPRECIATION, EDUCATION, SUPPORT…DID I SAY EDUCATION AND SUPPORT???? I think you get my drift…